According to Shane Co., the most popular bagel in the Garden State is the "everything" bagel. More like a round sub than a usual breakfast bagel lolWhere Is The Best Bagel Shop In New Jersey? A post by FinanceBuzz selected a bagel shop in Monmouth County as the place to visit for delicious bagels in Jersey. The report cited Bagel Masters in Shrewsbury as a great place for a delicious bagel. "Renowned for its oversized, fluffy bagels, Bagel Masters offers a delightful variety of flavors and toppings and maintains a 4.6 Google rating."