He's hit three home runs in the last two games (wins) — just when the Yankees needed them most. Chisholm is not Judge, but he's otherwise the Yankees' best all-around athlete and their best hope to re-ignite the offense while Judge recovers. Don Mattingly, his manager in Miami from 2020-22, and Derek Jeter, a part-owner, tried to talk sense into Chisholm. Yankees manager Aaron Boone has tried his own version of the tough-love approach with uneven results. On Monday, he hit two home runs against Pirates starter Braxton Ashcraft, leading the Yankees to an 8-5 victory.