With the bases loaded and two outs, Schlittler surrendered a single to Nathan Lukes, who dumped the ball into right field. Judge made a limp and awkward throw to Jazz Chisholm Jr., who wasn't even serving as the cutoff man. Chisholm seemingly caught the ball in an unexpected manner, and by the time he turned around the second runner had scored. Here's a look at Aaron Judge's first throw in a game since late July: pic.twitter.com/5TuwjTls57 — Bryan Hoch ⚾️ (@BryanHoch) September 5, 2025Aaron Judge injury concerns mount after bizarre throw, postgame Yankees commentsThe Yankees ended up losing 7-1 and fell four games behind Toronto in the AL East. In Judge's defense, he was asked 17 times if he was healthy enough to play outfield at a 100% effort, just in different contexts from different reporters.