For nearly 40 years, John Sterling served as the radio voice of the New York Yankees, delighting (and at times frustrating) fans with his whimsical accounts of the happenings on the field. It seemed like the Yankees picked up a winner in his replacement, Dave Sims, the longtime Seattle Mariners TV broadcaster who was lauded for his work in the Pacific Northwest. New Yankees radio man Dave Sims gets some harsh criticism for his performance as he replaces the legendary John SterlingAwful Announcing asked its readers to grade their local MLB radio broadcast teams, and the feedback for Dave Sims was not kind. The veteran radio woman served as the inspiration for Sterling's classic line, "That's baseball, Suzyn," which only served to highlight their on-air cohesiveness. If Sims takes all the criticism in stride, look for this booth to generate much more favorable reviews next year.