Penning emotional track 5s initially wasn’t something the powerhouse did with intention. “As I was making albums I guess I was just kind of putting a very vulnerable, personal, honest, emotional song as track 5,” she explained at the time. “Picking a track 5 is a sort of pressurized decision,” Taylor told her longtime friend and collaborator, Jack Antonoff. While we wait for the latest track 5 song, “Eldest Daughter,” to drop along with the rest of The Life of a Showgirl, there’s no better time to revisit Taylor’s emotional musical journey. Here are all of Taylor Swift’s track 5 songs, ranked (though you better believe we’ll revisit once “Eldest Daughter” is here).