CCTV from St John shows Sarm Heslop boarding a dinghy with her boyfriend and vanishing into the Caribbean night. “She was always up for a new challenge… totally run-of-the-mill for Sarm to just be doing something bonkers,” her friend Zan told the BBC. In Coast Guard records, Bane told authorities they returned to Siren Song around 10 p.m. “There was… nothing of evidentiary value that points to Sarm having contact with anyone that night, outside of Ryan,” Brooks told the BBC. Cattie acknowledges the conviction but stresses there is “absolutely no indication” of violence between Bane and Sarm.