The long-running dispute stemmed from the rescheduled FKF Division One clash against Nakuru Bucks FC, played on Friday, 26th September 2025, at the Ulinzi Sports Complex. The high-stakes fixture was abandoned in the 86th minute with Gucha Stars leading 2–0, after the assistant referee was accosted by fans in the venue. The incident forced officials to stop the match, leaving the final outcome hanging in the balance.