A new study looked at what pumpkin products people in the state are searching for online and pumpkin pie came in first by a long shot. On average New Yorkers type in “pumpkin pie” over 20,000 times every month. Whether made with fresh sugar pumpkins or canned pumpkin it’s a true fall favorite. Pumpkin Bread Takes the Second SpotComing in second is pumpkin bread with more than 10,000 searches a month. It’s a rich creamy alternative to pumpkin pie made with a spiced graham cracker crust and a smooth pumpkin cream cheese filling.