In Caught Stealing, Austin Butler plays a man whose life is upended when he agrees to look after his neighbor’s cat. Tonic the cat is ‘Caught Stealing’ the show in a new action comedy The fluffy Siberian forest cat upstages Austin Butler, Zoe Kravitz, Regina King and Bad Bunny in the new action comedy Caught Stealing. By his grisly standards, the darkly funny crime thriller Caught Stealing comes across as a lighter affair, even though it has a sky-high body count and its protagonist loses a kidney in the first half-hour. As a funny, bloody valentine to the city during a bygone era, Caught Stealing is awfully engrossing, though I can’t say that its mix of rambunctious slapstick and bone-crunching violence always gels. When it comes to his villains, Aronofsky plays broadly with cultural stereotypes, sometimes spinning them in outlandishly violent directions.