From just fine to eat-the-whole-pint, here are all the Ben & Jerry’s Non-Dairy flavors ranked from fine to best based on mix-ins, balance of flavors, and my personal preference. What are Ben & Jerry’s non-dairy flavors made of? & Cookies were officially Ben & Jerry’s first non-dairy flavors, and all were made from a base of almond milk. As of Spring 2024, all of Ben & Jerry’s non-dairy pints are made with the new oat milk base. 16 non-dairy Ben & Jerry’s ice cream flavors, rankedDon’t let decision fatigue keep you from enjoying a pint of Ben & Jerry’s.