Carey is an Arizona-based partner at the law firm Hagens Berman Sobol Shapiro LLP, which leads the proposed class action against Fenix International Limited and a class of so-called "chatter" agencies that claims the companies engaged in civil fraud and racketeering. Carey recruited a few plaintiffs through his "Save the Fans" campaign, which was advertised across social media websites such as X. As AVN reported most recently about the case that was filed in 2024, attorneys representing Fenix and its affiliate companies noted that Carey and his colleagues used false and/or incorrect artificial intelligence (AI) hallucinations. The OnlyFans attorneys maintain that the plaintiffs should not be permitted to refile updated and corrected filings. They also maintain that the case should be dismissed.