At the same time, the case is marked by deep, unresolved questions that go to the heart of justice and to Jewish moral duty. Supporters say those alternative leads were not thoroughly pursued once the investigation focused on Jewish suspects. For nearly a decade, Ben-Uliel’s supporters say he has endured extreme isolation. Legal remedy in Ben-Uliel’s case has, for now, been exhausted in the courts. For those who accept the possibility that Amiram Ben-Uliel’s confinement reflects not only punishment but also potential miscarriage, the mitzvah of Pidyon Shevuim remains urgent.