It is true that theology is a discipline of mysteries, but, while theologians can be philosophers and storytellers, they are also investigators. Our goals were to develop researcher capacity in, and the wider field of, “psychology-engaged theology” in particular. Working with a psychologist as a mentor, they designed 12-month, small-grant research projects to gain practical experience in psychology-engaged theology research. The result has been a supportive community of psychology-engaged theologians who have now “left the nest” and are independently pursuing new research trajectories in this field. You, too, can be part of psychology-engaged theology.