Haley Kalil says her comments about Matt Kalil's penis are protected by free-speeach, but experts think he might still have a case. Haley Kalil said she was shocked that her ex-husband, Matt Kalil, filed a lawsuit against her over claims she made about his penis size. Why is Matt Kalil suing Haley KalilEarlier this month, Matt Kalil filed a lawsuit against his ex-wife, Haley Kalil, for a comment she made during a Livestream appearance last year. She has asked a judge to dismiss the caseShortly after news of Matt Kalil’s lawsuit went public, Haley issued a public statement. The motion also argues that the statement she made about her former marriage and Matt Kalil’s penis was “autobiographical.” A ruling has not yet been made.