During the segment, Cross asserted that extremist groups had effectively disappeared because, she claimed, their members had become federal immigration officers. “Did you just say ICE officers are militia?” he asked. O’Leary pressed Cross again, asking whether she was claiming ICE officers were part of a “Proud Boy militia.” Cross denied using that exact phrase but criticized O’Leary for disputing her assertions. The exchange escalated when Cross alleged that ICE agents had “White supremacist tattoos.” O’Leary asked her to clarify whether she was accusing federal law enforcement officers of being White supremacists. White supremacists, federal officers,” Cross said.