The limited hours actually add to the appeal, creating a sense of anticipation and making each visit feel more special. Apple Pie That Surprises With Real FruitWhile the key lime pie gets most of the glory, the apple pie at Pie and Plate deserves its own standing ovation. The chicken pot pie isn’t traditional in presentation, but it’s packed with delicious filling loaded with tender chicken and fresh vegetables. Multiple reviews specifically call out the pot pie as a must-order item, with one long-time customer naming it the best thing on the menu. Whether you’re stopping by for lunch or picking up dinner to go, the chicken pot pie delivers comfort food satisfaction without the fuss of a traditional pot pie presentation.