The Presidents led 37-34 at halftime, but Chatham scored 50 points in the second half. W&J was led in scoring by Michael Plasko’s 17 points, 13 of which came in the first half. Chatham led 68-66 before embarking on an 8-1 run that gave the Cougars a 76-67 lead with only two minutes remaining. Casey Keesee netted 17 points and Jackson Rhodes had 11 for Waynesburg (2-7, 6-12), which shot only 33 percent and committed 20 turnovers. Waynesburg led 31-24 at halftime and used a 22-11 scoring margin in the third quarter to pull away.