The best drugstore mascaras of 2026, which for the most part top off around $20, come in an abundance of cutting-edge formulas that lengthen and lift the lashes. Don’t forget about the brown drugstore mascaras out there, too: masters of subtlety that act generously towards those with fair skin or lighter-colored hair. And don’t let their name fool you: Drugstore mascaras can be shopped outside of your local brick-and-mortar store. At WWD, Cigliano frequently tested and reviewed top-rated products like drugstore mascaras. Sullivan personally tested multiple drugstore mascaras on this list, backing up claims with her rigorous, first-person reviews.