But have you sampled the unofficial fall topping of Illinois, Pumpkin butter? Illinois pumpkin butter is the next step. Yes, you quite possibly can find pumpkin butter at farmer’s markets and roadside stands, and you should purchase a jar of pumpkin butter locally if you can. Farmstead foods Illinois/Canva/Google Street View Farmstead foods Illinois/Canva/Google Street View loading...Twidley Bits – Chicago, IL. - make and distribute their own Pumpkin Butteryaegers farm market/Canva/Google Street View yaegers farm market/Canva/Google Street View loading...Read more: Missouri is Ready to Pour You a Hard Cider‘Tis the season to smear some pumpkin butter across your baked goods.